Why include music therapy in a neuro-rehabilitation team?
Posted in Rehabilitation Articles on 1st Oct 2019
Wendy L Magee, PhD, is a Music Therapist Clinician and Researcher, working with adults with complex needs from acquired brain injury and neuro-degenerative disorders since 1988. Her published research covers: evidence-based music interventions in neuro-rehabilitation including a Cochrane Review; measurement; Disorders of Consciousness; identity following disability; and new and emerging music technologies in healthcare.
Correspondence to: Wendy L.Magee PhD, Professor, Boyer College of Music and Dance, Presser Hall, 2001 North 13th Street, Philadelphia, PA 19122, USA. Email: email@example.com
Conflict of interest statement: None declared.
Provenance and peer review: Submitted and externally reviewed
Date first submitted: 23/7/19
Date submitted after peer review: 13/9/19
Date of acceptance: 17/9/19
Published online: 1/10/19
Interdisciplinary neuro-rehabilitation programmes can be enhanced by including music therapy as music interventions can incorporate a patient’s goals across behavioural domains. Neurologically, music is intrinsically motivating, drives motor function and elicits emotional responses. Incorporating live music delivered by trained and qualified professionals ensures interventions are tailored to patients’ needs and goals, assisting with engagement and adherence to treatment. The evidence for the effects of music therapy in neuro-rehabilitation is reviewed, with reference to a recent Cochrane Review.
- Music therapy with neurological populations typically engages the patient in active music-making, with the therapist playing live music and adapting musical components moment-by-moment to both meet patient needs and challenge the patient to reach goals
- In neuro-rehabilitation, interventions range across song-writing to address psychosocial needs, singing and vocalising exercises to target communication goals, and playing instruments or moving to music to meet motor goals
- Neurologically, music is intrinsically rewarding and motivating, activating neural networks throughout the brain that influence non-musical behaviours, and resulting in changes to brain structures
Music therapy: what is it and what is involved?
The rationale for including music therapy as part of an interdisciplinary rehabilitation programme may not be immediately obvious: unlike other professions that address function within a more clearly defined domain (e.g. physiotherapy for movement disorders; speech and language therapy for speech/language disorders; psychology for cognitive disorders) music therapy addresses function across domains. As defined, music therapy is the clinical and evidence-based use of music interventions to accomplish individualised goals within a therapeutic relationship by a credentialed professional who has completed an approved music therapy programme.1 A common misconception is that music therapy is passive listening to recorded music. However, when delivered by a trained professional, music therapy typically actively engages the patient in live music-making, targeting active health goals, with the therapist adjusting musical parameters (tempo, dynamic, rhythm, pulse, melody, harmony) moment-by-moment in immediate response to the patient’s functioning.
Internationally, professionals trained as music therapists are required to adhere to professional standards and codes of conduct: in the UK, music therapists are registered with the Health and Care Professions Council. Music therapy interventions are distinguishable from recreational activities, as they are individually tailored to the individual, goal directed and planned by a health professional. Interventions vary considerably, even when targeting goals within the one domain (i.e. motor; psychosocial; communication) but fall into two broad categories: active or receptive methods.2 Active methods used in neuro-rehabilitation include: song-writing; music-making using acoustic or digital MIDI instruments; movement to music including gait training to rhythmic music or metronome; and singing or vocalising. Receptive methods include: music listening to live or recorded music; and imagery to music. Dosage for effective music interventions vary widely in terms of the number and frequency of contacts, the duration of individual contacts and course of therapy, and the mode of delivery (individual or group).2 Dosage is dependent on the targeted outcome, stage of rehabilitation and setting, so standard recommendations cannot be made.
Why include music therapy in a neuro-rehabilitation team?
The theoretical rationale for using music in neuro-rehabilitation centres upon music’s innate competencies within humans, its cross-cultural purpose for social bonding across cultures, and its neurological capabilities in both healthy and neurologically damaged populations. Music is a universal phenomenon that exists in all known human societies and is considered distinctive to the human condition.3 Cross-culturally, humans engage in musical activity through singing and instrument playing as part of creative play and within ritual. So music is a familiar, meaningful activity with many inherent associations, even for those who are musically untrained. Music is also a social activity, a medium for engaging with others in meaningful collective practices4 and assists with managing social relationships.3 Thus, it facilitates social bonding and interaction as music-making is rarely a solitary activity. In western societies, music-making is realised through singing in choirs and ritual practices and playing instruments in bands and orchestras. Group singing is conducive to social bonding5 and has been found to be a stress-reducing activity as measured through reductions of adrenocorticotropic hormone,5 cortisol and cortisone.6
However, the strongest argument for including music therapy in neuro-rehabilitation lies in its neurological benefits. Neurologically, music is intrinsically rewarding as it activates brain regions involved in reward, motivation, emotion, and arousal.7 Cortical changes in brain damaged patients during music interventions indicate activation of bilateral networks across the frontal, temporal and parietal lobes, cerebellum and limbic areas, stimulating cognitive, motor, and emotional processes.8-10 When integrated with repetitive rehabilitation exercises and drills, music that is tailored to an individual’s performance can enhance the motivation to sustain engagement and may improve patient mood and enhance motivation.11
Music therapy interventions in neuro-rehabilitation: practice and evidence
Music boosts cognition in the brain damaged patient, with reported effects on arousal, attention, orientation, memory, executive function, spatial neglect, and mental flexibility. For patients with Disorders of Consciousness (DOC), maintaining arousal is a significant problem and can interfere with optimal engagement in rehabilitation. Using music that is salient to the patient has been found to promote behaviours indicative of arousal and selective attention12, increase behavioural responses that indicate discrimination13 and awareness.14 Music therapy within interdisciplinary care may prime patient responsiveness in DOC,15 which is particularly useful when part of co-treatment: a music therapist will play live music that is personally salient to the patient, adjusting musical parameters to help the patient achieve and maintain an optimal state of arousal so as to engage in treatment sessions. Music has also been found to improve orientation for patients in post-traumatic amnesia.16 Following middle cerebral artery stroke, music interventions have been shown to be superior in enhancing cognitive recovery, more specifically verbal memory and focused attention, when compared to a language intervention (patient selected audio book listening) or a control condition (standard rehabilitation).8 Similar results have been found with mild traumatic brain injury patients, where music training in the form of eight weeks of piano tuition resulted in significantly improved results in executive functions related to attention, learning strategies and memory retrieval.17 Thus, music interventions have demonstrated positive effects across the spectrum of brain damage.
Of all behavioural domains with neurological populations, the strongest evidence for music interventions is with motor disorders. Motor regions within the cortex are sensitive to and driven by auditory stimuli as the auditory system processes temporal information rapidly and precisely, creating entrainment between a rhythmic signal and movement.18 In healthy subjects, movement to music results in superior physical performance: running for longer, lower perceived exertion, and slower exhaustion.19 These beneficial effects are increased when agency is incorporated into a workout, that is, that the physical movements result in musical sounds.20 These observations support the growing body of research examining the influence of music with a strong beat on gait disorders and upper limb function in adults with stroke and acquired brain injury. A Cochrane Review examined the effects of rhythmic auditory stimulation (RAS) on gait velocity, cadence, stride length, stride symmetry, gait and balance.2 RAS is a therapeutic intervention using rhythmic pulse to improve gait or gait related aspects of movement. Using live music, the therapist can embed the rhythmic pulse into the music for the patient to move to, or a metronome alone can be used. Based on 10 randomised controlled studies (n=298) the meta-analysis found beneficial effects for RAS on gait velocity, stride length, gait cadence and general gait in people with stroke, although the degree of improvement across studies was inconsistent.2 Subgroup analyses indicated that RAS interventions using live music with the beat embedded in the music may be more effective than using a metronome alone in addressing gait velocity and cadence. These findings highlight that although RAS can be implemented within interdisciplinary rehabilitation by non-music professionals using a metronome, the inclusion of a music therapist in the rehabilitation team using live music may enhance the intervention’s benefits. Music provides an intrinsic motivational reward, and using live music enables components (such as tempo, dynamic tension, harmonic tension and resolution, melodic direction) to be adapted in the moment to the patient’s movements, driving these movements to goal attainment.
Music interventions are used to rehabilitate upper limb function following stroke, measuring outcomes such as timing of movement, strength, hand function, manual dexterity, range of motion and elbow extension angle2 and often in co-treatment with occupational therapists. Interventions typically involve the patient playing strategically placed musical instruments in live music making: the therapist commonly manipulates rhythm and tempo in the accompanying music to guide the patient’s movements, but harmonic and melodic tensions are also used. A number of studies have examined neural reorganisation during these interventions, noting coupling between the motor and auditory cortices.11 The benefits for involving music therapy in team treatment include motivation and adherence to treatment of motor disorders.21
Communication outcomes are frequently targeted with music following stroke and traumatic brain injury, as it has long been noted that people with severe non-fluent aphasia have greater success when singing lyrics than speaking the same words.10 Although speech and music are neurologically distinct, they share pitch, timing and timbre cues to convey information at an acoustic level and at a cognitive level both demand complex cognitive skills: memory, attention, and the ability to integrate acoustic events and perceive these according to rules of syntax are required by both.22 Music, like language, has structural rules for production suggesting a deep connection between the two within the brain. Intensive music interventions to address language production with people with severe non-fluent aphasia have resulted in neuroplastic changes to connections across brain regions.10 The acts of speech and singing additionally share musculature for respiration, phonation, articulation and resonance.23 Music therapy interventions address communication goals through singing and vocalising, often in co-treatment with speech and language therapists. Singing interventions address non-fluent aphasia, dysarthria, dyspraxia, dysprosody and dysphonia measuring outcomes such as words produced, speech intensity, naturalness and intelligibility, rate control, articulation, phonation and prosody.2,24 Melodic intonation therapy is an intervention frequently used to target language production in expressive aphasia, engaging right-hemispheric structures through tapping of the left hand and intoning words in a melodic contour that imitates speech prosody.10 Numerous case reports describe the benefits of a number of music interventions to improve communication, supported to some extent in research suggesting benefits to overall communication, naming and repetition.2 Further research would consolidate these findings and improve the widely varying protocols that have been reported.
Lastly, music therapy interventions are reported to improve psychosocial functions such as behavioural outcomes, emotional needs, mood, well-being, social skills and quality of life.2 Psychosocial sequelae are integrally related following brain injury: communication or behavioural difficulties impact upon social relationships, risking feelings of isolation and depressed mood, reducing quality of life. Music therapy can reduce agitation in patients with post-traumatic amnesia.16 The intersectional nature of psychosocial subdomains can be addressed through therapeutic music-making as a meaningful social experience that enhances social bonding3 and stimulates emotional experiences. Music therapy will typically use active music interventions such as song-writing, improvisation and song-singing to address mood, identity reconstruction and emotional expression in neuro-rehabilitation.2 These can be powerful interventions when delivered in groups and may also incorporate members of the patient’s social support network. Individually tailored music listening programmes in the acute recovery phase post-stroke have resulted in less depressed and confused mood states than standard rehabilitation.8 More research is needed examining the effects of music interventions on all aspects of psychosocial functioning.
Music provides a familiar salient stimulus that activates widespread neural activity and has the potential to be harnessed to improve functioning across all the behavioural domains, including motor, cognition, communication and psychosocial. Thus, music therapy is well-placed as an intervention in neuro-rehabilitation. Music is also ubiquitous and easily accessible with the swipe of a screen, but its use is not without risk, particularly the possibility of triggering strong emotional reactions. The application of music interventions in neuro-rehabilitation thus requires planned and careful application with vulnerable populations by professionals trained in its use.
- American Music Therapy Association. Definition and Quotes about Music Therapy [Internet]. Silver Spring MD: American Music Therapy Association; n.d. [cited 2019 July 15]. Available from https://www.musictherapy.org/about/quotes/https://www.musictherapy.org/about/quotes/ .
- Magee WL, Clark I, Tamplin J, Bradt J. Music interventions for acquired brain injury. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2017(1). https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD006787.pub3/abstract
- Trehub SE, Becker J, Morley I. Cross-cultural perspectives on music and musicality. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 2015 Mar 19;370(1664):20140096. https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rstb.2014.0096
- Dissanayake E. An ethological view of music and its relevance to music therapy. Nordic Journal of Music Therapy. 2001 Jul 1;10(2):159-75. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/08098130109478029
- Keeler JR., Roth EA, Neuser BL, Spitsbergen JM, Waters DJM, Vianney JM. (2015). The neurochemistry and social flow of singing: bonding and oxytocin. Frontiers in human neuroscience. 2015;9:18.
- Fancourt D, Aufegger L, Williamon A. Low-stress and high-stress singing have contrasting effects on glucocorticoid response. Frontiers in psychology. 2015:6;1242.
- Blood AJ, Zatorre RJ. Intensely pleasurable responses to music correlate with activity in brain regions implicated in reward and emotion. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2001 Sep 25;98(20):11818-23.
- Särkämö T, Tervaniemi M, Laitinen S, Forsblom A, Soinila S, Mikkonen M, Autti T, Silvennoinen HM, Erkkilä J, Laine M, Peretz I. Music listening enhances cognitive recovery and mood after middle cerebral artery stroke. Brain. 2008 Feb 20;131(3):866-76. https://academic.oup.com/brain/article/131/3/866/318687
- Särkämö T, Tervaniemi M, Huotilainen M. Music perception and cognition: development, neural basis, and rehabilitative use of music. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science. 2013 Jul;4(4):441-51.
- Schlaug G, Norton A, Marchina S, Zipse L, Wan CY. From singing to speaking: facilitating recovery from nonfluent aphasia. Future neurology. 2010;5(5):657-65.
- Street AJ, Magee WL, Odell-Miller H, Bateman A, Fachner JC. Home-based neurologic music therapy for upper limb rehabilitation with stroke patients at community rehabilitation stage—a feasibility study protocol. Frontiers in human neuroscience. 2015;23;9:480. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnhum.2015.00480/full
- O’Kelly J, James L, Palaniappan R, Fachner J, Taborin J, Magee WL. Neurophysiological and behavioral responses to music therapy in vegetative and minimally conscious states. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. 2013;25:7:884.
- Castro M, Tillmann B, Luauté J, Corneyllie A, Dailler F, André-Obadia N, Perrin F. Boosting cognition with music in patients with disorders of consciousness. Neurorehabilitation and neural repair. 2015;29;(8):734-42.
- Verger J, Ruiz S, Tillmann B, Ben MR, De MQ, Castro M, Tell L, Luauté J, Perrin F. Beneficial effect of preferred music on cognitive functions in minimally conscious state patients. Revue neurologique. 2014;170(11):693-9.
- Magee WL. Music in the diagnosis, treatment and prognosis of people with prolonged disorders of consciousness. Neuropsychological rehabilitation. 2018;17;28(8):1331-9.
- Baker F. The effects of live, taped, and no music on people experiencing posttraumatic amnesia. Journal of Music Therapy. 2001;38(3):170-92.
- Vik BM, Skeie GO, Vikane E, Specht K. Effects of music production on cortical plasticity within cognitive rehabilitation of patients with mild traumatic brain injury. Brain injury. 2018;16;32(5):634-43. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02699052.2018.1431842
- Thaut MH, Abiru M. Rhythmic auditory stimulation in rehabilitation of movement disorders: a review of current research. Music Perception: An Interdisciplinary Journal. 2010;1;27(4):263-9.
- Terry PC, Karageorghis CI, Saha AM, D’Auria S. Effects of synchronous music on treadmill running among elite triathletes. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport. 2012;1;15(1):52-7.
- Fritz TH, Hardikar S, Demoucron M, Niessen M, Demey M, Giot O, Li Y, Haynes JD, Villringer A, Leman M. Musical agency reduces perceived exertion during strenuous physical performance. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2013;29;110(44):17784-9.
- Street AJ, Magee WL, Bateman A, Parker M, Odell-Miller H, Fachner J. Home-based neurologic music therapy for arm hemiparesis following stroke: results from a pilot, feasibility randomized controlled trial. Clinical rehabilitation. 2018;32(1):18. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0269215517717060
- Kraus N, Chandrasekaran B. Music training for the development of auditory skills. Nature reviews neuroscience. 2010;11(8):599.
- Wan CY, Rüüber T, Hohmann A, Schlaug G. The therapeutic effects of singing in neurological disorders. Music perception: An interdisciplinary journal. 2010;1;27(4):287-95.
- Tamplin J, Baker FA. Therapeutic singing protocols for addressing acquired and degenerative speech disorders in adults. Music Therapy Perspectives. 2017;17;35(2):113-23.